Ok, here we go. It may be a bit hard and a bit soon, but here we go.
I get regular requests from photographers to do a photo shoot with them. It surprises me because if they had taken a look at my profile, they probably would have come to the realization that I am not what they are looking for: I am not attractive, I am not soft and pretty; I am broken and don’t come across well, but they usually don’t look. They just see a young girl into kink things and think she will be perfect. It’s my fault too. We all do it, we see what we want, or what we fear in my case.
I usually will write the photographers back and explain that we probably are not looking for the same thing. I try to explain that the thing they do with the bright colors, the vivid tones, the sharp angels and even the focal length, well it’s the opposite of everything I want. Typically they initially show some sort interest in learning about my desires as I think its pretty natural for people to want to have a beautiful, or, better said, lovely, photo and so I begin to tell them. I tell them about the grayed out photo with low contrast that is so grainy it is difficult to make out the details. I tell them about the small girl with enormous white space. A girl, a tragic girl emerging from the water, the shallow waves still tossing around her legs as she somehow walks to higher ground, to safety, along the water. I picture her with wings because I do so love that image, still pure, holy, someone who didn't compromise but didn't drown either. The people to whom I tell this always feign interest and sometimes go so far as to tell me that that is something they are capable of creatinng, that it is a picture they want or can make happen but that they just prefer another type.
Do you know the etymology of the word barbarian? Greek. It means foreigner. That’s all. Originally it had very little context towards it. Into the 14th century that took a different direction and it became closer to how we would now think of the term. But initially, it just meant someone from outside. They called them barbaros because to the Greeks, or so its said, the words the foreigners spoke sounded like "bar bar."
Do you want to know what I found so interesting about the Romans compared to the Greeks? The Greeks were so focused on Greek-ness. Indeed it took that version of other to help define them. For the Roman it was far more about improving roman-ness by expansion. More romans, stronger romans, less non-romans. They made settlements in Britain, in Syria. It’s a different mindset. I think it is easier to see the threat level change. When you are only concerned about your role you don't worry so much about the foreign words but when those foreigners are out to conquer the world, to conquer you, it becomes another story.
I sometimes will have the photographers write me for months, telling me that we should get together and try to take some photos. They’ll send me links to their portfolios and I will look and I will see the same things over and over again: the girl will take the obvious center stage, she will be the neon light and you will be forced to pay attention to her, to see her, instead of the subtly, the devotion, the attention and time needed with my version, with hunting for the girl.
Do you want to know another word I have spent some time researching lately? Narrow-minded. Want to guess the first time the word came up? 1615. Want an idea of the things going on at that point? The Jews were being killed by the Roman Catholic Church, Galileo was proposing that we could use Jupiter as a way of determining longitude but the church was about to tell him he needed to stop with this theory about the earth revolving around the sun, explorers had just rounded the Cape of Good Hope, Christian missionaries were band from Japan, Notre Dame cathedral was about to reach completion, Pocahontas was just married-and along came the term narrow-minded.
Things have changed in some ways I suppose. History, of course, is still written by the victors: look at Galileo. He won didn’t he? What would you say to the devout mothers who stand outside packed school board meetings demanding that intelligent design be taught along side evolution. Crazy right?
Sometimes I try to show the photographers examples of what I’m looking for but it is becoming harder and harder to find. I told this recently to a guy I met who replied as if it were entirely obvious, that naturally my types of images are becoming harder and harder to find: people don’t want to find them anymore, they are *archaic* and not the direction people are moving. People want things that are brighter, more modern and free.
A few months ago I did try to meet with a photographer, back when I was still willing to try any type of photography(er) and see if maybe I would love the way it came out. Ever have to apologize for absolutely detesting something someone has shown you of himself or herself?? It was an awful feeling, having to look at him and tell him how much I really, truly hated the pictures he had taken of me. I was ashamed because I knew he had worked hard. He put up with me for goodness sakes! I know how hard that is. It was an awful moment. I was ashamed and tried to keep all of how I felt to myself: that I was ugly, that I looked garish, that I felt too exposed, that I looked like a slut, gluttonous. None of it was because of him though, he had done a nice job with what he wanted but it just wasn’t at all what I wanted. It wasn’t what made me happy and wasn’t something that I really thought I would grow to like. But he was only able to keep taking the photos in the way he wanted.
Therefor, when another young man approached me a few days ago and said that he was pretty sure he would be able to match what I wanted to do but that I had to act quickly and take him up on the offer, and when I said that I wasn’t interested, that I wanted nothing to do with it, he became angry and I became defensive. He said I should stop being stupid and take him up on the offer to do it for free, because other people would charge me, would be mean about it and he would be patient. I called him the day after and tried to explain how I felt after the last go round of photos but he was already insulted that I told him that his photos were ugly. Truth is, I didn’t. It was me that was ugly in that light, in that style. But it’s what he heard and he left me some bitter, immature, angry messages. He said I was judging him. He said I was contaminating his creativity and to get away from him, out of his life. To not bother him or anyone he knew again. That I was awful.
Why write all this? Why spend this much time on a photo? Remember the three life goals? Remember the sub goals? To have one beautiful photo. I want to be remembered the way everyone does. Positively. Beautifully. And I love the idea of a snap shot being able to summarize. Who hasn’t found an old photo in an album and been struck by something? By raw emotion, by the clothing, by the light, by the expressions? There is something simplistic and powerful that lasts through that. I like to think it’s the lighting and the eyes but then I have a fascination with light (it is God after all right?). Anyhow, enough new age. Remember those people who used to think that taking a photograph of someone were to steal their soul?
What if it were true? What if what we showed in that snap shot, in that moment was the one thing for which we would be remembered? The one thing we would be remembered as? And all of our thoughts and values had to be caught in that. Where would you go to look for the photos you wanted to see? I know I’m not going to a casino. I'd go to the docks perhaps. To the ships coming to port and loved ones waiting, waiting for that one special person in their life. It’s the photo I would want to see. I don’t know why anyone interested in long stockings and purple lipstick would ever look at my profile. And why they would ever hope to find themselves there.
But then I guess I can’t see why the photographer, or myself would push so hard for our versions of beauty. I think it’s the Romans. I never felt like I was in Greece. I always felt that I had to be aware, that the empire was spreading. I think I was trying to find someone who didn’t hear everything I said as "bar bar." I think I wanted someone to recognize that there is another type of beauty and in that, I think found only ugliness: the threat of the sharpness, contrast.
But when I hear them telling me that I should try their way again, that the world now teaches evolution... I want my Polaroid.
I want to save myself in a locket that I can give to my master one day. Show him who I was, how I was. That even though I felt I was drowning so often, that I felt pulled under, that I felt to survive I had to compromise, that even though all that was true, I tried and I fought. Now, lying on the beach, my wings are wet and I am tired and I can’t stand anymore. I want him to find me anyhow. I want him to see me through the static and think I was worth it, think I was special enough to take all his time even in muddy shades of gray, even without a flash.
I love photos. The promise they entail and the threat. The camera lies every day. It shows happiness when there should be tears, it shows love when there is nothing. It can be used to make any statement you need. The lengths everyone needs to go to find the picture they want of themselves, it's hard enough, made harder when you're told there is a certain way you should look, should act. And I say it, and I see it in the photos of myself. And more and more I lose myself in those. And instead, we see our fears. And when we act on the fears, the beauty that we wanted to show, is all forgotten.
I read this article recently for Christians who are hearing people telling them that they needed to be more open-minded (oddly this phrase didn't come for a few centuries after narrow-minded). The argument is for when you're being told that by keeping your beliefs you are being closed-minded even if the person talking to you is the one who wont hear you. The argument essentially goes: listen. Start by just listening and learning. Then, after you have listen to what the other person is saying tell them a story of yourself, a story of your own failure, of your own humility and how you had to ask forgiveness. Then ask the person with you, invite the person With you, to open themselves up and tell of the last person from whom they asked forgiveness because to ask forgiveness is to see it in another light, to open your heart and mind to something else.
I know I will never be beautiful under those bright lights. But those aren’t the lights that I think show beauty. I want simple lighting. I know with enough lighting, with enough, it’s easier to be beautiful but I want a simple beauty that won’t hide when the lights turn off, or wash away at night.
I went to Four Square Church months ago and remember their music. It was so full of everything: Triangles, Guitars, Pianos, everything. Comparing that with the Gregorian Monks and their simple chanting; that is what I want in my photo. Intrinsic beauty where the less there is, the more each part is shown entirely and has to be beautiful. I love that.
That is my view of beauty. Sometimes, It's hard to talk to photographers who have different goals and different values and different views of beauty. I wish I knew how to do so better, to talk with no hope on anyone’s part of changing the other’s beauty.
I'm still developing and I'm still looking. I guess it might be too soon still but I’ll keep looking for the photographer and the commissioner.